undergradly.
Private College

Otterbein University

Private College in Westerville, OH. Six-year graduation rate 68%. Median 10-year earnings $53,313.

Verdict Mixed outcomes
Otterbein University · Campus
Median earnings · 10 yr
$53,313
Median debt at grad
$26,000
Mobility score
1.2
% bottom→top quintile
Graduation rate
67.9%
Federal loan default
0%

The median ten-year earnings figure of $53,313 sits near the national middle rather than at either extreme. 68% graduate within six years, so most students who start here finish here. Graduates carry a median of $26,000 in debt — in line with the national norm.

Earnings: College Scorecard, median ten years after entry across students who received federal aid — completers and non-completers alike.

Green Flags
  • 3-year loan default 0.0% — below national benchmark
Red Flags

Admissions

Acceptance rate
85%
Applicants
3,923
Yield rate
17.7%

Otterbein University accepts 85% of applicants, which makes it accessible to most students who meet the baseline requirements. The applicant pool runs to 3,923, typical for a school of this reach. Only 18% of admitted students enroll — the great majority of admits go elsewhere or nowhere. Read the score bands below narrowly: only 25% of enrolled first-years submitted an ACT score, and test-optional applicants are not represented in them.

Test score bands (middle 50% of submitters)

These bands describe the enrolled first-years who submitted a score, not the entering class. Where most students apply test-optional the submitters are a self-selected, higher-scoring group.

Test 25th–75th percentile Submitted
SAT Evidence-Based Reading
SAT Math
ACT Composite 22–28 149 (25%)

IPEDS Admissions · 2024

Apply at Otterbein University →

Academics

Full-time retention
80%
Transfer-out rate
19%
Student:faculty
12:1

68% of students finish within six years, putting completion well above the national norm. First-year retention of 80% shows the cohort holds together through the hardest year. Retention and completion are close, which places the gap between entering and finishing almost entirely in year one. A 19% transfer-out rate accounts for part of that gap: those students left for another institution rather than dropping out, and the graduation rate above counts them as non-completers here. At 12:1, students get materially more instructor contact than at a typical public university.

Financial Aid

Average net price
$20,457
Full-time, first-time undergraduates paying the in-state rate who were awarded grant or scholarship aid
% receiving grants
98%
degree- or certificate-seeking undergraduates
% receiving federal loans
55%
degree- or certificate-seeking undergraduates

IPEDS Student Financial Aid · 2023-24 · grant and loan rates against 2,056 degree- or certificate-seeking undergraduates

Net price lands at $20,457 a year on average, neither cheap nor punishing. Aid is steeply need-based: families in the $0–30k band pay $12,458 while those at $110k+ pay $24,620. Grant aid is widespread — 98% of students receive it, averaging $24,048. Most students borrow — 55% take federal loans to cover the gap.

Entering first-year students

A different, smaller group than the rates above: full-time students in their first year of college anywhere. The grant series here also excludes the "other sources" counted in the all-undergraduate figure, so the two are not comparable.

% receiving grants
100%
Average grant
$27,923

IPEDS Student Financial Aid · 2023-24 · 519 students

Net price by family income

The same students as the headline above, limited to those who received Title IV federal aid — a narrower group, with a lower overall average. IPEDS publishes no combined figure across these bands, so they should not be averaged into one.

Family income band Average net price
$0–30k $12,458
$30–48k $12,659
$48–75k $16,478
$75–110k $23,061
$110k+ $24,620

IPEDS Student Financial Aid · 2023-24

Federal student loans went to 1,126 of these 2,056 students, totalling $7,397,734 — an average of $6,570 each.

IPEDS Student Financial Aid · 2023-24

Local housing costs

Typical rents near campus (Franklin County) — budget these against any cost-of-attendance housing estimate.

Studio
$1,111/mo
1 bedroom
$1,194/mo
2 bedroom (whole unit)
$1,430/mo

HUD Fair Market Rents (40th-percentile gross rent incl. utilities) · FY2026

Veterans & GI Bill

GI Bill students
52
Yellow Ribbon
Yes
Principles of Excellence
Yes

VA GI Bill Comparison Tool (Veterans Affairs GIDS)

Compare Otterbein University with peer institutions

How we evaluate Otterbein University

IPEDS
US Department of Education
College Scorecard
Post-grad earnings
Census PSEO
Earnings by major
Opportunity Insights
Mobility by institution
Read our full methodology →